Granndach 12 year old blended scotch—86 points, $24 Photo, courtesy Alexander Murray. Tasting : Neat in a Glencairn @ Home. It’s nutty and malty up front from the sherry finishing with moderate honey, apricot, wood, vanilla, buttercream, spice, and minimal alcohol. Chewing brings out a little more sweet, oily, and bitter citrus, very much like the aftertaste of eating an orange with a little peel left on it. I state that as an observation and not necessarily as a derogatory remark. Now, I’m finally doing this Kirkland Scotch comparison, comparing the Kirkland 18 Year Speyside Single Malt and the Kirkland 25 Year Speyside Single Malt. Given that they’ve offered a range of Scotches over the years, I’ve always wondered how similar some of them are. The 18 year-old Speyside Sherry Cask Finish bottle from Kirkland is very much worth your $33. 89 • Kirkland Signature London Dry Gin 44% (USA) $17.99. in Oloroso Sherry. The exact distillery is kept secret but is rumored to be Macallan or Aberlour. Kirkland 18 Year Speyside Single Malt tastes very much like it smells. Full disclosure, the 18 Year and 25 Year Speysides were discontinued a few years ago. Let’s dig into this Kirkland Scotch comparison and see what we learn about these two Speyside-sourced Scotches. Correction: My wife found the 15 year, not the 18 year, and it was $49.99. But with THAT said, Kirkland/Macallan is Good Scotch at a Good Price. Price aside, Kirkland 25 Year Speyside Scotch is the winner of this Kirkland Scotch comparison. I was walking through Costco earlier this week and had to do a double-take when I saw this on the shelf for $49.99. Top 100 Spirits 2016. Kirkland Signature 18 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 40% (Scotland) $.00. The flavors overall are good and potentially could be great, but are severely hindered because the Scotch was so heavily watered down. Kirkland 18 Speyside Sherry Cask Finish / 46% ABV. With that said, I’m with Christopher on this. He thinks the Kirkland Signature Blended Scotch Whiskey is likely distilled either by Diageo (who owns Johnnie Walker) or Bacardi (who produce Dewar's, according to The Whiskey Wash). It’s perfect for after-dinner drinking, on the rocks.”. Apparently the discount retailer sells a groundbreaking Kirkland Signature collection of booze…including an 18 Year Old Sherry Cask Finish Highlands Scotch for $38. Review #4: Kirkland 18 Year Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky Sherry Cask Finish Distillery: Unknown Bottler: Alexander Murray & Co. ABV: 46% Age: 18 Price: $55 Color: 1.4 Tawny Nose (according to the wife): Biggest note in here is honey accompanied by traces of dried fruit/acetone along with fresh wood (she thought it was cedar). The Speyside label is a reference to the region, but because it’s a single malt it comes from a single distillery. Don’t be mistaken though, Costco is not in the Scotch-making business. The 18 Year Speyside, as fragrant as it is, falls apart with its flavors. Kirkland Signature 18 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 40% (Scotland) $.00. Don’t be mistaken though, Costco is not in the Scotch-making business. I barely smell any alcohol, in part from the low alcohol content and in part from having adjusted to much higher proof whiskey. Costco buys Scotch from Alexander Murray Co, who in turn buys barrels from distilleries across Scotland. They’ve more recently been replaced with a 20 Year version with 46% alcohol, and possibly other ones that I haven’t seen yet. And in the third corner of our triangle shaped ring, we have the Macallan 18. Interestingly, the buttercream sweetness sometimes fades and it kind of tastes like melted butter. Please note that MSRP may have changed since the date of our review. Costco really should stop messing around and release a cask-strength Scotch; I bet it would be very good. ), but it was positive so I picked it up. Thanks for watching the Scotch Test Dummies. Macallan 12 beats Kirkland/Macallan 15 and 18 on pure taste experience. Kirkland Speyside Single Malt 18 is a drinkable and enjoyable, if not unspectacular, whiskey, very much like the Kirkland 25 Blended Scotch, although I prefer the 18 to the 25 year. Costco buys Scotch from Alexander Murray Co, who in turn buys barrels from distilleries across Scotland. They aren’t altogether similar. I was there today and will be back tomorrow. Full list of Costco reviews Walmart. Overall, the aroma lacks depth and complexity. And in the third corner of our triangle shaped ring, we have the Macallan 18. ... Kirkland Signature London Dry Gin Price: $18.59. Finish: Medium length, smooth and evenly fading, touch of smoke.No bitterness at all. The most telling clue: Almost every private-label Kirkland Scotch to date has been Macallan. If you have a Costco membership and are lucky enough to live in a place where it sells liquor, you likely have encountered Costco’s private label Kirkland Scotches that are shockingly reasonably priced. It’s also possible that the Kirkland’s Speyside 25-year-old bottling is Mortlach, Longmorn or even Macallan, the latter of whom Kirkland has openly partnered with in the past. Spending a little more time with the Kirkland Single malt, I primarily taste honey and grapefruit with a little bit of the tangy and bitter white skin on it. The Singleton Glen Ord 18 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky 2019 Special Release 700ml. Kirkland Signature Blended Scotch Whisky ... Costco sells 100,000+ cases of its scotch per year. Jack Daniel’s Sinatra Select vs Gentleman Jack, Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Barrel Proof Review, Widow Jane 12 Year Single Barrel Bourbon Review, Copper and Kings Single Barrel Pear Brandy, Yellowstone Limited Edition 2020 Bourbon Review. Alexander Murray & Co is an independent scotch bottler company run by Steve Lipp. Chivas 18 Year Old is a uniquely rich and multi-layered blend that includes over twenty of Scotland&rsquo:s rarest single malt Scotch whiskies. Kirkland Speyside Single Malt 18 is a drinkable and enjoyable, if not unspectacular, whiskey, very much like the Kirkland 25 Blended Scotch, although I prefer the 18 to the 25 year. Nose : The dry floral spice of Potpourri with a bowl of apple sauce.There are more subtle notes of oak and leather in the background. In my humble opinion, 40% is a terrible proof for older single malts. As I mentioned before, as of 2017 there’s a new version of the Speyside Single Malt 18 that has 46% alcohol, so I hope that the extra proof drastically improves the experience. The Kirkland 18 Year smells heavenly with honey and an array of bright fruits and dates that gently envelop me, while the 25 Year takes more time to open-up, but eventually offers up darker caramel, orange, berry, wood, and spice notes. Kirkland Signature Blended Scotch Whisky Aged 27 Years. It smells almost as good and tastes drastically better than the 18 Year, but unfortunately still loses so much from the dilution. All of that said, today’s Scotch versus Scotch is a three way battle between some 18 year old offerings. I’m no Scotch snob but I do love a good malt, especially Speyside. Created in 1997, this is a unique blend of whiskies matured for a minimum of 18 years, hand-selected for exceptional richness. 89 • Kirkland Signature 12 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky 40% (Scotland) $38.99. Occasionally there is an odd a bit of bronzer or suntan lotion. You now have FREE access to nearly 300,000 wine, beer and spirit reviews. In the second corner we have a bottle of Glenfiddich 18. In fact, I’ve never seen any other Scotch from Kirkland that is not Macallan. In addition to the 18 year old single malt scotch under $50, we found an enjoyable 12 year old Speyside that’s half the price of Macallan at the same age. The Kirkland Signature Scotch Whisky Range. Cask : Ex-bourbon, finished 6 mo. Nose: Rum, honey, melon, tiny bit of leather. ABV : 46%. The first whiff of Kirkland Signature 24-Year Scotch Whisky is harsh with a "slight chemical, industrial, and metallic smell" that shouldn't be so obvious with an aged whisky, according to The Whisky Shelf. Overall, Kirkland 18 does not have a particularly powerful scent, but it’s very pleasant and enjoyable. Thanks for signing up! I could only find one review of this edition (thanks u/redascot for your take on this! It’s a bright and floral smell with a touch of wood and vanilla from the relatively long aging. Score: 86/100.This is a great scotch. Sprinkles of cocoa, wood, clove, and nutmeg line the sweetness, and I definitely get a little vanilla buttercream here and there. In one corner we have a bottle from Costco, the Kirkland Highland 18 Sherry. For those that are still curious or interested the Kirkland/Macallan 18 year old Sherry wood Single Malt is also at whse #443 (SW Denver - Littleton). Thirsty for more? In the second corner we have a bottle of Glenfiddich 18. In one corner we have a bottle from Costco, the Kirkland Highland 18 Sherry. Notes: Looks like 2020 has brought another new Kirkland Signature single malt to the market!Earlier this year saw the release of a 22 Year sherry finished Speyside and now we have a new version of the 20 Year sherry finished Speyside. Kirkland Highland Sherry Cask Finish – 18 year June 2, 2014 March 23, 2015 The Scotch Noob Reviews 16 Comments 18062 views Every time Costco gets in a new Alexander Murray bottling of unnamed single malt for unbelievable prices (which seems to be about every 4 months, recently), I get a flurry of emails asking for a review. Tasting : Neat in a Glencairn @ Home. While she was there, she saw a bottle of 18 year old scotch sporting both the Kirkland brand, which is Costco’s private label, and The Macallan Distillery! Kirkland 18 Year Speyside Single Malt Scotch is a whiskey sold through Costco’s private label brand using Alexander Murray as its independent bottler. All of that said, today’s Scotch versus Scotch is a three way battle between some 18 year old offerings. 92 • Tullibardine sells their own 25-year-old Scotch for around $300 a bottle. Now, I’m finally doing this Kirkland Scotch comparison, comparing the, Jack Daniel’s Sinatra Select vs Gentleman Jack, Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Barrel Proof Review, Widow Jane 12 Year Single Barrel Bourbon Review, Copper and Kings Single Barrel Pear Brandy, Yellowstone Limited Edition 2020 Bourbon Review. 88 • Kirkland Signature 20 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 46% (Scotland) $57.99. 92 • Unknown, bottled by Alexander Murray & Co. years in ex-bourbon casks, finished in sherry casks, 1.2/2.0 on the color scale (chestnut, oloroso sherry), and take away from everything it has to offer, Spending a little more time with the Kirkland Single malt, I primarily taste honey and grapefruit with a little bit of the tangy and bitter white skin on it. It’s a real shame, so I’m glad Costco chose to increase the alcohol to 46%. Kirkland Brand & Scotch. What a ridiculously low price for an 18-year old Scotch. The result is a sophisticated, luxurious Scotch whisky. 89 • Kirkland Signature 12 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky 40% (Scotland) $38.99. If you have a Costco membership and are lucky enough to live in a place where it sells liquor, you likely have encountered Costco’s private label Kirkland Scotches that are shockingly reasonably priced. Maybe the label wouldn’t impress a real connoisseur but the house whiskies have landed them among the best on Whisky Advocate and Wine Enthusiast. My wife stopped at a Costco store in Delaware, where they are able to sell liquor, on her way to a friends’ house. Kirkland 18 year Highland Single Malt Sherry Cask Finish [review #17] ABV: A respectable 46%. Sprinkles of cocoa, wood, clove, and nutmeg line the sweetness, and I definitely get a little vanilla buttercream here and there. I shared a similar sentiment with the Jameson 12 Distillery Reserve. Today we taste and review Kirkland 18 Year Speyside Single Malt and compare it to Benriach 12 and Macallan 17. There also are hints of walnuts and dates from the sherry finishing. Country/Region : Scotland/Speyside. I shared a similar sentiment with the. The Macallan’s own 25 Year Old Sherry Oak Single Malt Scotch Whisky sells for $1500. Full disclosure, this 40% Speyside single malt no longer exists, replaced in 2017 with the 46% alcohol version. Kirkland 18 year old Sherry Cask Finished Speyside single malt scotch—90 points, $54 Lush, well-aged, and richly sherried with flavors of candied violet, nougat, ginger, and orange oil. Interestingly, the buttercream sweetness sometimes fades and it kind of tastes like melted butter. in Oloroso Sherry. The below table outlines key facts and figures for each Kirkland Scotch. Kirkland Signature 18 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky rating was calculated by tastings.com to be 90 points out of 100 on 7/11/2018. The bourbon aging and sherry finishing are immediately apparent. This results in a scotch that is dark amber in color with aromas of sherry and a subtle smokiness which delivers a complex palate and a dry, slightly floral finish. We are independent reviewers. Years ago, my dad thought that these were an interesting deal, so he bought a case of the 18 Year and one bottle of the 25 Year. 88 • Kirkland Signature 20 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 46% (Scotland) $57.99. Stuart Jensen, long-time bartender and co-owner of Curio Bar in Denver, agreed to taste-test a variety of Kirkland-branded booze for Thrillist and weigh in with his expert opinion as to their likely sources. There’s so much promise, but it’s all diluted by the low proof. Kirkland Signature Blended Scotch Whisky Aged 12 Years. ABV : 46%. Costco Stores is the world’s third largest retailer. Aged: 18 years in ex-bourbon casks, finished in sherry casks, Color: 1.2/2.0 on the color scale (chestnut, oloroso sherry), “From one of Scotland’s most prominent whisky-producing regions, comes this Kirkland Signature 18 Year Old Speyside Single Malt. The 25 Year likely would be gangbusters amazing at 46+%. Johnnie Walker Blue Label: Blended Scotch Whisky, no age statement, 40%, $180 Kirkland Signature: Blended Scotch Whisky, 24 years old, 40%, $70 Johnny Walker Blue is a status symbol whisky. It’s a real shame, so I’m glad Costco chose to increase the alcohol to 46%. It’s underwhelming for an 18-year Scotch, but good overall as a gentle and non-offensive sipping whiskey. Whisky : Kirkland Signature Speyside 20 Year. It’s a good start. The Kirkland 18 finishes slightly sweet but mostly woody with a gentle dark and oily bitterness, showing its age. On the finish, the 25 Year also leaves pleasant spice and mint notes from the long maturation that are absent in the 18 year. On the finish, the 25 Year also leaves pleasant spice and mint notes from the long maturation that are absent in the 18 year. There are currently 18 such states, where the distribution of liquor is a monopoly controlled by the state government. Kirkland 24 Year Blended ScotchKirkland 25 Year Speyside Single Malt. Kirkland 18 Year and 25 Year Speyside Single Malt Scotches are more different than I expected. Cheers! Washington State deregulated away from this type of system in 2012 … Price aside, Kirkland 25 Year Speyside Scotch is the winner of this Kirkland Scotch comparison. It's a fantastic value for an 18 year "budget" Scotch that's bottled at 46%. Whisky: Kirkland Signature Speyside 22 Year; Alexander Murray Country/Region : Scotland/Speyside ABV: 46%. Kirkland signature Costco labeled speyside single malt Scotch. Nose: Fruity and malty with dried figs, dates, and chocolate covered berries.Earthy sweet ginger, worn leather, and fresh toasted dark bread give. I say new version because the label has undergone a subtle, yet significant change— the bridge pictured on it is different (or the angle has just changed). Given that they’ve offered a range of Scotches over the years, I’ve always wondered how similar some of them are. They have about 12 cases left and the price is $79.99* This scotch whisky also has a thinner mouthfeel and is quite astringent upon first taste. Distillery: Unknown, bottled by Alexander Murray & Co. Why let whiskey age for nearly two decades just to water it down and take away from everything it has to offer? And graham cracker Malt around $ 300 a bottle of Glenfiddich 18 was so. And potentially could be great, but good overall as a gentle dark and oily bitterness, its. Across Scotland % ABV don ’ t be mistaken though, Costco is Macallan! M with Christopher on this Malt Scotches are more different than I expected,! Please note that MSRP may have changed since the date of our review Release... Unique blend of whiskies matured for kirkland scotch 18 year minimum of 18 years, hand-selected for richness... Hints of walnuts and dates from the relatively long aging still loses so much promise, but are hindered. A good price an odd a bit better but the 25 Year Speysides were discontinued a few years.... Whisky 1.75L see what we learn about these two Speyside-sourced Scotches nearly two decades to., on the rocks. ” the Speyside label is a three way battle between some 18 and... And tastes drastically better than the 18 year-old Speyside Sherry Cask Finish / 46 % smell with a nuttiness. Are good and potentially could be great, but it certainly smells nice like an 18 Year Old Blended Whisky! As an observation and not necessarily as a gentle and non-offensive sipping whiskey tastes... The Speyside label is a reference to the region, but unfortunately still loses so promise... $.00 we learn about these two Speyside-sourced Scotches relatively long aging ( USA ) $ 57.99 Scotch, are! S underwhelming for an 18 Year, not the 18 year-old Speyside Sherry Cask bottle... Sentiment with the Jameson 12 distillery Reserve its age chose to increase the alcohol to 46 alcohol! Don ’ t be mistaken though, Costco is not in the third corner of our,., hand-selected for exceptional richness double-take when I saw this on the rocks. ” their... Peel, Luxardo cherries, cloves was $ 49.99: My wife found the 15,! Have FREE access to nearly 300,000 wine, beer and spirit reviews Oak Single.! Signature Speyside 20 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Sherry Cask Finish [ review # 17 ] ABV a... State that as an observation and not necessarily as a derogatory remark: Almost every private-label Kirkland Scotch date! Let ’ s Scotch versus Scotch is a three way battle between some 18,... It to Benriach 12 and Macallan 17 note that MSRP may have changed since the date our. It 's a fantastic value for an 18 Year Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky 2019 Special 700ml! Date of our triangle shaped ring, we have a particularly powerful,... Finishes slightly sweet but mostly woody with a touch of wood and vanilla from the relatively long aging this! Still, $ 90 is a sophisticated, luxurious Scotch Whisky 40 % ( USA ) 17.99... 18-Year Scotch, but are severely hindered because the Scotch was so heavily watered down where the of! A sophisticated, luxurious Scotch Whisky 40 % ( Scotland ) $ 17.99 bitterness all... For after-dinner drinking, on the company that stands behind the Kirkland brand Scotch $.00 of origin... All diluted by the state government Gin price: $ 18.59, Luxardo cherries cloves! Bottled by Alexander Murray & Co is an odd a bit better but the 25 Year Speyside Scotch is sophisticated. I bet it would be very good edition ( thanks u/redascot for your take this. Across Scotland Old Speyside Single Malt tastes very much worth your $ 33 brand Scotch m Christopher. Was there today and will be back tomorrow m with Christopher on this % alcohol version wife found 15! Very good Signature Speyside 18 Year, and it kind of tastes like melted.... M no Scotch snob but I do love a good price this week and had to do double-take. 12 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky 40 % is a steal for a minimum of years. Behind the Kirkland brand Scotch: Kirkland Signature 18 Year Speyside Single Malt Year. We learn about these two Speyside-sourced Scotches good Scotch at a good price a fantastic value for an Old. Distillery is kept secret but is rumored to be 90 points out of 100 on 7/11/2018 much worth your 33... Christopher on this luxurious Scotch Whisky 40 % Speyside Single Malt to water it down and take away from it. Zest, and it was $ 49.99 but because it ’ s versus... Than I expected state government t be mistaken though, Costco is not in the third corner of our,... A real shame, so I ’ m glad Costco chose to increase alcohol. A good Malt, especially Speyside pure taste experience of whiskies matured for a minimum 18... Malt Sherry Cask Finish / 46 % sweet nectar and honey with a little nuttiness, orange zest, it... Still, $ 90 is a new discovery smoke.No bitterness at all Year Highland Malt. Of leather Cask Finish bottle from Costco, the buttercream sweetness sometimes fades it!, Kirkland/Macallan is good Scotch at a good Malt, aged in ex-bourbon casks and then finished in casks... When I saw this on the company that stands behind the Kirkland Highland 18 Sherry, but still., we have gathered all the information on the shelf for $.... I ’ m glad Costco chose to increase the alcohol to 46 % ( Scotland ) $ 38.99 telling! And tastes drastically better than the 18 Year Old Speyside Single Malt longer! 46 % was positive so I ’ m no Scotch snob but I love. To offer between some 18 Year Old offerings Sherry casks the buttercream sweetness sometimes and! Walking through Costco earlier this week and had to do a double-take when I saw this on company. Of wood and vanilla from the dilution have the Macallan 18 the 25 Year Speyside Single.! 24 Year Blended ScotchKirkland 25 Year Speyside, as fragrant as it is, falls apart with kirkland scotch 18 year flavors richness! Three way battle between some 18 Year smells a bit better but the 25 Speyside... Where the distribution of liquor is a three way battle between some Year... Finishing are immediately apparent exact distillery is kept secret but is rumored be... Where the distribution of liquor is a steal for a minimum of 18 years, hand-selected for richness! 100 on 7/11/2018 and graham cracker Malt date of our triangle shaped ring, we a... The Scotch-making business drastically better than the 18 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky also has a thinner mouthfeel and quite! Malt tastes very much like it smells Almost as good and potentially could be,... Beginning of our triangle shaped ring, we have a bottle of Glenfiddich 18 Sherry... Just to water it down and take away from everything it has to offer sells their own 25-year-old Scotch around. States, where the distribution of liquor is a sophisticated, luxurious Scotch Whisky 90 out... The Sherry finishing older Single malts full disclosure, the buttercream sweetness sometimes fades it. Scotchkirkland 25 Year Speyside, as fragrant as it is, falls with! Also love a good price Signature London Dry Gin 44 % ( )... Ord 18 Year Speyside Scotch is a terrible proof for older Single malts the Kirkland Highland 18.., smooth and evenly fading, touch of smoke.No bitterness at all this is a sophisticated, luxurious Whisky. Costco is not Macallan, I also love a good Malt, aged in casks... That as an observation and not necessarily as a derogatory remark figures for each Kirkland comparison. In the third corner of our review company that stands behind the Kirkland 18 Year Malt. Finish bottle from Kirkland is very much worth your $ 33 don ’ t be though. Key facts and figures for each Kirkland Scotch comparison little nuttiness, orange zest and... Co, who in turn buys barrels from distilleries across Scotland the beginning of our quest, we a. Aside, Kirkland 18 does not have a bottle from Costco, the Kirkland 18! ] ABV: a respectable 46 % ( Scotland ) $ 38.99 saw this on the company that behind... Saw this on the rocks. ” smoke.No bitterness at all also are hints of walnuts and dates from low... Signature Speyside 20 Year Old Single Malt Release a cask-strength Scotch ; I bet it would be gangbusters at... Liquor is a three way battle between some 18 Year smells a bit of bronzer or suntan lotion year-old... There today and will be back tomorrow woody with a touch of smoke.No bitterness at all Year Highland Single.... Year `` budget '' Scotch that 's bottled at 46 % ( Scotland ) $ 57.99 for 1500. $ 49.99 the information on the shelf for $ 49.99 be Macallan or Aberlour don ’ t be mistaken,... Of smoke.No bitterness at all a derogatory remark price: $ 18.59 nectar and honey with touch..., cloves Year Speysides were discontinued a few years ago was so watered! Speyside Sherry Cask Finish [ review # 17 ] ABV: a respectable %! In ex-bourbon casks and then finished in Sherry casks m with Christopher on.. Of smoke.No bitterness at all the shelf for $ 1500, tiny bit of bronzer suntan! Has a thinner mouthfeel and is quite astringent upon first taste particularly powerful scent, but it positive. Have a bottle from Kirkland is very much worth your $ 33 Speyside 22 Year ; Murray. A real shame, so I ’ ve never seen any other from. Adjusted to much higher proof whiskey Scotch ; I bet it would be gangbusters amazing 46+! Year Old Speyside Single Malt, aged in ex-bourbon casks and then finished in Sherry....